Book review: The House of Doors by Tan Twan Eng
One of my favourite reads of the past decade was The Garden of Evening Mists by Tan Twan Eng. In fact, I would honestly call it life-changing. So I was both eager and nervous to read Tan’s latest book The House of Doors.
Again, Tan explores Malaysia’s history through his fiction. But in this case, half the characters are real people.
In 1920s Penang the white European colonisers keep themselves largely separate from the local Malay and Chinese population. Lesley Hamlyn has lived her whole life in the Malay Peninsula, but now her British husband Robert’s health is deteriorating fast. His doctor recommends a move to South Africa, which Lesley dreads but knows is inevitable. It’s a bad time for house guests, but famous writer Willie Somerset Maugham is in the region and wants to drop in for two weeks.
When Willie shows up with his secretary Gerald, Lesley is initially repulsed by the discovery that they are a gay couple. Then she discovers that Willie may have news of the Chinese revolutionary Dr Sun Yat Sen, stirring up memories of her own friendship with Sun a decade earlier.
Willie becomes her confidante. But the story of her flirtation with politics is tangled up with a notorious court case in Kuala Lumpur. One of Lesley’s close friends was arrested for murder in 1910, and during her trial, Lesley travels down to see her a few times and hear her story.
When Willie arrives in Penang he’s stressed about money and life, and struggling to write. The stories Lesley tells him are rich fodder for his pen but they do include some pretty big revelations about herself. In return for Lesley’s discretion about Gerald, will Willie keep her secrets?
“Each morning, as dawn began to thin the darkness around him, he would go down to the beach for a brisk walk. The crescent moon was a Cheshire cat’s grin in the sky, fading away into morning. The stretch of the bay in front of Cassowary House was about a quarter of a mile long, lined with four or five mansions spaced far apart and screened from the beach by tall casuarinas. At the end of the bay was a stream, barely two strides across, simmering over the shallow sand bed as it siphoned the rains from the mountains to feed the sea’s unquenchable thirst.”
To add yet another wrapper to the tale, the novel starts and ends in South Africa in 1947, where Lesley has lived for 25 years. So we know from the outset that Lesley was forced to leave her beloved home shortly after these few weeks spent with Willie.
With so many threads, tangles of real history and invention, The House of Doors could have been messy or overstuffed but it’s not. I thought it brilliant. Not as high in my estimation as The Garden of Evening Mists but I still rate Tan highly. I will have to seek out his first book The Gift of Rain.
As with The Garden of Evening Mists colonisation is a major theme in The House of Doors, if less explicitly so. The British occupation appears genteel by comparison with the Japanese one, and Tan doesn’t get into the more brutal realities of it. But you can read between the lines the artificiality of the white European enclaves. And the unfairness and prejudice it’s all built on.
That said, I do find it interesting that a Malaysian author has chosen to write a historical novel set in Malaysia with no Malay characters – well, not main characters anyway. I suppose that itself could be a commentary on how the British treated empire.
Lesley is an interesting lead character. She has her racist moments, though less so than most of the other white characters in the novel. She speaks fluent Hokkien, much to the bemusement of her friends. And while like all her peers she casually refers to grown men as “houseboys”, she at least uses the servants’ actual names when speaking with them. She’s a little cold and rigid, but she has depth.
“The sun slipped into a hidden seam in the clouds, and the world faded to monochrome. I wiped my palm, put on my glove and stepped out into the street. Before I left I gave one last look at the doors, and then I walked back the way I had come, back to my own world.”
The relevance of the title doesn’t become clear until the last third or so of the book. It’s an original, romantic idea and probably my favourite part of the book, but to discuss it would be far too spoilery.
Most of all, though, the writing is beautiful throughout. Even with not exactly loveable characters I was engrossed.
Published 2023 by Canongate Books.
Source: Heron Books, Bristol.
Leave a Reply